What Makes Him the Supersleuth?

"Holmes, described by Conan Doyle as "the most perfect reasoning and observing machine that the world has seen," isn't actually a particularly likable character, or even a very fully realized one. Raymond Chandler once remarked that Holmes "is mostly an attitude and a few dozen lines of unforgettable dialogue." He is languid, aloof, arrogant, supercilious and a bipolar druggie who in "The Sign of Four" is shooting up cocaine three times a day to overcome his lassitude. He has no friends other than Watson, and Mr. Lanza notwithstanding, he is almost certainly a virgin. In fact, there is something slightly inhuman about Holmes, though somehow that only adds to his appeal. We're fascinated by him, it seems, precisely because he is a kind of cipher, unlike anyone else we know or even have read about."

Leia o texto completo aqui.